nabil laoudji

poetry, prose, design thinking & entrepreneurship

  • HOME
  • PORTFOLIO
    • Audio
    • Video
    • Poetry
    • Prose
  • CONTACT

Amazon & Wikileaks: Sorting Out the Controversy

December 6, 2010 by Nabil 1 Comment

Amazon’s recent decision to pull Wikileaks from of its servers has sparked a heated debate. I think one of the main points that’s been confused is Amazon’s legal versus ethical obligations. Here’s my attempt to sort these out:

Legally the argument is simple. Amazon forbids the hosting of documents that a client does not “own or otherwise control all of the rights to.” Wikileaks did not (or so let’s hope) write the Department of State diplomatic cables and so they’ve clearly violated the Terms of Service (TOS) to which they agreed when they signed up for an account. A clear TOS violation. Suspend the account. End of story.

Ethically the argument falls into a gray area, and I think your opinion on the matter is intrinsically tied to the value you put on the cables. If you consider the cables nothing more than someone’s stolen personal property, then again Amazon is right not to be an accessory to theft. On the other hand, if you consider the cables as information that’s illuminating a greater social injustice, then the argument gets trickier.

Say, for example, a North Korean soldier leaks stolen government documents detailing a network of heretofore unknown hard labor camps, and posts these docs on Amazon’s server. Some would argue that for Amazon to take down his site out of respect for the property rights of the North Korean regime would be at best, ethically questionable and at worst, aiding and abetting a large social injustice.

Now whether you believe the Wikileaks documents illuminate any social injustice well, that opinion’s yours to form ;)

Filed Under: Stream Tagged With: internet, law, wikileaks

Comments

  1. Shehab says

    December 6, 2010 at 2:28 pm

    The TOS you reference is pretty clear-cut.

    The other TOS mentioned in the Amazon post: “that use of the content you supply … will not cause injury to any person or entity” on the other hand is far more subjective and in effect means Amazon becomes an editorial gatekeeper of sorts for content stored on its cloud.

    Regardless of where you come down on the ethical question, it does seem that this sort of information sharing will become a part of the diplomatic landscape moving forward. There’s no turning back and diplomacy will evolve accordingly.

    Interesting times!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Welcome

Nabil Laoudji Twitter LinkedIn Instagram More Info

Recent Tweets

  • What’s cool about history is that it keeps repeating itself with better technology 🥲 about 4 months ago
  • .@LUMAInstitute Think-Aloud Testing hits TikTok #designthinking https://t.co/OI9PTlvwaY about 4 months ago
  • RT @usopen: That final feeling 🙌 Ons Jabeur and Iga Swiatek will battle for the women's singles title! @Cadillac Iconic Moments | #USOpen… about 4 months ago
  • RT @WTA: 😘 Two worthy #USOpen finalists 🙌 @iga_swiatek | @Ons_Jabeur https://t.co/WrO5W4now7 about 4 months ago
@laoudji

Recent Snaps

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins

Error: No posts found.

Make sure this account has posts available on instagram.com.

Click here to troubleshoot

Recent Comments

  • Don on How meditation helped me get a handle on compulsive thoughts
  • Shehab on Amazon & Wikileaks: Sorting Out the Controversy
  • Mike on On Purpose
  • Katherine Molina on On Purpose
  • Anne on On Purpose

Archives

Tags

AI arab spring boston buffalo business career comedy community democracy design thinking Entrepreneurship ethnography family film improv india interview landscape launch learnings lessons los angeles massmouth MBA meditation mental health MIT music NYC occupy oprah passion performance ethnography public speaking revolution risk rust belt sales standup storytelling story tips tunis tunisia ucb values

Thanks

Thanks for visiting!

Copyright © 2023 · Metro Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in